Amwell, AliveCor, GSR Ventures and American Telemedicine Association at Invent HealthRead more...
Everything from increased visibility to better primary care are helping to bring costs down
With healthcare reaching nearly 18 percent of GDP in 2018, it's almost impossible to talk about any aspect of the space without discussing cost and how to reduce it.
That topic inevitably came up when Vator and HP held its latest salon, called The Future of Clinics, in which a group of entrepreneurs from startups such as Heal, Solv, Crossover Health and One Medical got together to discuss the changing way that care is being delivered, and what that means for the future of the doctor's office.
The panel, moderated by Bambi Francisco Roizen (Founder and CEO, Vator) and Archana Dubey (Global Medical Director, HP), featured Dr. Pat Carroll (Chief Medical Officer, HIMS/HERS), Jenni Vargas (Chief Strategy Officer, One Medical), Yumi Diangi Taylor (founder of TeraPractice at Sutter Health/ Palo Alto Medical Foundation), Karoline Hilu (Chief Strategy Officer, Crossover Health), Justin Zaghi (Chief Medical Director, Heal), Heather Fernandez, (co-founder and CEO, Solv Health) and Mona Chadha (Chief Strategy Officer Bay Area, Dignity Health).
Francisco brought up the topic of cost by noting that, "I think outcomes are important, but as important are costs. We need to be improving our outcomes while hopefully reducing the costs to the overall industry. And hopefully if we reduce our cost with technology then we can address those people who can’t afford it.
"How have you integrated technology? Where are you saving the cost? And, if you have a social mission to your business, how do you set aside some of that to take care of some of these other consumers who need help paying for their healthcare?" she asked the panel.
Carroll, who recently left his position at Walgreens to join telehealth platform HIMS, spoke first.
"It solves a lot of problems. You don’t have to have a telehealth visit, you can actually have a chat with the physician, answer your questions, high quality care, and care quality is table stakes and then get the product delivered. So, today we probably only do eight products, but everything that I did in retail health at Walgreens, 30 diagnoses can be done off our platform. It’s going to take a little time to build it up, but it will be done. So we’re going to look at asynchronous communications, deliver retail health at a minimum type care on the platform. That’s pretty unique," he said.
HIMS only costs patients $5 a visit, which, he noted, is "a big savings. That’s what excited me about coming to HIMS and why I’m not at the $110 billion company now."
Cost savings have always been something important to him, Carroll said, and he related a story about when he worked for a health system to reduce admissions and readmissions that led him to help reduce cost for the company's own employees.
"The CFO pulled me aside and said, ‘You’re doing too good of a job. I’m paying money for you to keep people out of my hospital. We make money in the hospital.’ True story. And so I said, ‘Well, that’s troubling,’ so I immediately said, ‘I’d like to meet with the CEO’ and the CEO said, ‘Pat, you didn’t understand. We wanted to be ready for value-based care, we didn’t want you to actually do it. Except for our own employees because we’re spending $179 million a year on our own employees, so I want you to direct all those programs to our own employees.’ That’s when I updated my LinkedIn and went to Walgreens soon after but we made a lot of progress with our own employees so when I came to Walgreens I said, ‘I get it. When we look at innovative programs why not start with our own employees?’
At Walgreens, he focused on care navigation, but also muscular skeletal problems, as one out of six dollars for large employers are spent on musculoskeletal injuries and are responsible for 35 percent their healthcare costs. They also focused on diabetes, partnering with companies like Livongo and Verily.
"For Livongo to reduce hemoglobin A1C by 1, what that means is a $6,500 per team member savings. And we have 50,000 pre-diabetics and 10,000 diabetics at Walgreens. We focused on appropriate care navigation, diabetes, musculoskeletal and flattened and reduced the cost. So it can be done, all of these programs and innovations that we’re talking about, sell it for your leadership around your own employees. There’s your ROI," he said.
For Sutter Health's Taylor, cost reduction comes from "bringing visibility of the cost to the provider," which TeraPractice does with a dashboard that allows them to what their spend looks like. Specifically, the company has been able to save when it comes to labs, imaging, specialty referral, drugs, and then the institutional side with hospitalization.
"The great thing is that we have visibility now and providers, care teams, have visibility to see how they’re performing in that area," said Taylor. "This will probably tie in more to how does the role of a doctor change, but this has become part of the larger scope of how we thing about delivering high value care."
One Medical's Vargas spoke next, explaining that "engaged, accessible primary care, which costs about six to seven percent of total healthcare costs, saves about 10 percent."
"How do we do that? A couple of things. We do 90 percent generics, or 100 percent generics on anything that has a generic; insulin doesn’t have a generic, for example, because our app does not all the provider to do anything but a generic. That was something that they though of very early on. The 24/7 accessibility means you don’t go to the urgent care; we have almost zero percent urgent care in our population, and about half the emergency room. And if you don’t go to the emergency room, you don’t get admitted, so our days per thousand are very low as well," she said.
Solv's Fernandez then spoke about cost savings at Solv, which, as she noted, is not a provider, "so when we think about reducing cost of care it’s around giving you visibility and access."
One of the first things that Solv tried to solve was reducing the number of unnecessary ER visits.
"Our first ‘ah ha’ when we were starting Solv was the volume of inappropriate ER visits, which people likely would be at the PCP if had access, but they don’t. I think the back of envelope was that if you shifted one percent of the ER visits to urgent care, you would save $1 billion in system savings. And I looked around and I was like, ‘Why isn’t anyone talking about this?’ So, that became the first problem that we tried to set up to solve," she said.
"Now, after two and a half years of operations, self reported by the consumer, 14 percent of those who booked online with us would have been in the ER, so by directing them to the appropriate side of care we estimate that’s around $150 million. That’s one way that we think about it."
The other thing that Solv does to lower cost is give patient more visibility around their own benefits.
"With high deductible health plans, on one hand it’s great because all of the sudden patients are paying attention. All of the sudden I am noticing $20 or $200 or $2,000. That is a noticeable number to me. So, one thing that we do there is just give them visibility on plan details and then effectively your progress against your deductible. On the individual provider side, we put ranges for basic CPT codes based on your insurance plans as our first step. The vision there is let’s get you to full detail so that we are giving you more data with precision. The step before that is to just give you some information because people are flying blind."
Francisco then addressed Zaghi and Taylor, noting their disagreement over the viability of Heal's business model, which revolves around delivery at-home doctor visits.
“You don’t have brick and mortar payments to make and that infrastructure. You believe it can scale. how does it scale? Explain that to us. It sounds somewhat expensive even though you don’t have the infrastructure. And then, Yumi, why don’t you think it can scale?" she asked.
While Zaghi admitted that "house calls are expensive," he also noted that a large part of a doctor's own expenses involve paying for an office.
"Despite that, you’re right, it’s still expensive to send a doctor to a patient, so our business model really varies based on the age demographic, we get paid differently by different payers as well. Medicare happens to be very profitable for us, because they tend to reimburse better, and we also have arrangements with Medicare Advantage plans where we have shared savings," he said.
Those shared savings, which come from the benefit of having a house call, actually make it so that Heal is able to come out on top.
"The benefit of a house call is obvious and well established: you’re in a patient’s home, you can assess all of the social determinants of health. You can see if the patient is poor, you can see if they’re smoking, you can see if they have trouble affording their medications because you actually have their pill bottles. So, the value is obvious there. And with those shared savings agreements, we’re reducing hospital utilization by 21 percent, we’re reducing ER utilization by 30 percent, we’re reducing readmission rates, so we’re capturing a portion of that value and that more than compensates for the increase in cost of delivering the house call," he said.
"For the other populations that aren’t on these Medicare Advantage plans, we’re increasingly moving toward value-based structure and we are using multi-modality care, meaning telemedicine, which is a lot less costly than a doctor, but it’s with someone who has already met the patient. It’s not Teladoc where you’re playing roulette and you don’t know which doctor you’ll get, so the doctor knows you and that enables us to deliver more health more cost effectively."
Taylor countered that, "it’s really inefficient to have our most expensive individual, the physician, traveling to perform his visits. While I don’t think there’s never a role for a home visit, I think that it would be a very, very very small percentage when you’re doing panel management. That would be my concern."
Read more from our "Invent Health" series
Share your stories; Feel inspired to appreciate times of solitudeRead more...
Eren Bali of Carbon Health, Bruce Harrison of El Camino Health, Sunny Kumar of GSR VenturesRead more...
Related Companies, Investors, and Entrepreneurs
Joined Vator on
Something is working in healthcare today–convenient care. This year, roughly 170 million people in the U.S. will receive quality, same-day convenient care on their schedule and on their terms. They’ll visit an urgent care clinic in their neighborhood, walk into a retail clinic at the drugstore or speak with a doctor on a video call from the comfort of their homes.
What’s incredible is that convenient, high-quality healthcare is shifting consumer expectations–today, 3 out of 4 consumers will not choose a doctor who can’t see them within one week. This demand for a better day-to-day healthcare experience now accounts for nearly 20% of ambulatory visits per year. And, it’s causing much of the healthcare industry to take note.
Yet still, lack of transparent, clear information and common consumer technologies makes it nearly impossible for you to feel like you can make a simple or fully informed healthcare decision. Calling around to multiple offices, waiting months for an appointment, spending hours in a waiting room, and struggling to understand your insurance is still very much the norm.
That's where Solv comes in. We partner with high-quality providers across the country who share our goal of making access to high-quality convenient care simple, friendly and transparent for consumers, the way it should be. We equip them with technology that improves the quality of your service and the performance of their practice. For consumers, we get them in front of a provider in just a few taps, by helping them know where they can go, when they’ll be seen, and how much it will cost. We are building a world where we can all access healthcare that is convenient and affordable.
Joined Vator on
Going to the doctor these days can be confusing, inconvenient, and stressful.
We knew it could be better, so we created a new kind of primary care. It’s a place you can go not only when you’re sick, but also when you want to improve your long-term health and wellness. Where the experience is built around people — not paperwork.
One Medical is a membership-based practice focused on making quality care more accessible and enjoyable for all. No more waiting forever in stuffy waiting rooms, being rushed through appointments, or getting lost in the healthcare maze. Our offices have beautiful, calming waiting rooms — not that you’ll spend much time in them. Our appointments start on time, and are longer than average so providers have time to really listen. We’re driven by a shared mission to transform healthcare by designing it around people’s real lives.
Joined Vator on
Hello. We welcome the chance to help you feel your best. Excellent, affordable health care, delivered with compassion, is what we stand for. Since our founding in 1986, we've made it our goal to create environments that meet each patient's physical, mental, and spiritual needs. We also believe this healing philosophy promotes the wellbeing of our staff and the places they serve.
Dignity Health is made up of more than 60,000 caregivers and staff who deliver excellent care to diverse communities in 21 states. Headquartered in San Francisco, Dignity Health is the fifth largest health system in the nation and the largest hospital provider in California.
Through teamwork and innovation, faith and compassion, advocacy and action, we endeavor every day to keep you happy, healthy, and whole.
Joined Vator onStarted career in DC - Capitol Hill, McCain2000 presidential. Cal undergrad. Start up life post Stanford business school. Built Trulia over 10 years. Founder/CEO Solv, working to make same day healthcare available. Mom of three (11, 8, 5).