Yahoo shareholders are now asking AOL to take over

Steven Loeb · November 12, 2014 · Short URL:

Shareholders are upset with Marissa Mayer's acquisition strategy, see core business as undervalued

Yahoo CEO Marissa Mayer has gotten a lot of flack recently from company shareholders regarding her leadership, with many going after the company's spending spree, in which it bought up a slew of startups, including 27 last year alone.

Many seemed to be giving Mayer the benefit of the doubt, especially given how much the company's stock has risen under her leadership... until the company had five quarters in a row of mounting losses, making it hard to justify the amount of spending it had to have taken to buy all of those companies. The company finally put a stop to that bleeding last month, but that may just be a temporary fix.

Investors are still not convinced that her turnaround plan will work, and at least two major shareholders are now actively courting AOL CEO Tim Armstrong to merge with Yahoo so that he can take over, according to a report from Reuters on Wednesday.

Here's the interesting part: Armstrong has reportedly been receptive to the idea, and is open to exploring it. No talks have taken place yet, though, and Armstrong would only go ahead with such a deal if it was "friendly," which I guess means only if Mayer is also on board with it. 

This is not the first time such a merger has been openly discussed. In September, Starboard Value LP sent a letter to Mayer, urging her to purchase AOL.

"[W]e believe a merger of AOL and Yahoo's core business may be one of the best ways to both fully seize the cost reduction opportunity and also to tax efficiently monetize Yahoo's noncore equity holdings," it said in the letter.

Shareholders, including Starboard, feel that Yahoo's core business is currently undervalued. The company currently has a market cap of $47.19 billion, while its stake in online e-commerce giant is $44 billion. Investors think that Yahoo's other assets, including Yahoo Mail and website, should be worth as much as $7 billion.

A merger between Yahoo and AOL, some believe, would make their combined company a major competitor to companies like Google and Facebook in the areas of video programming and the purchase of digital advertising.

Yahoo just took a big step toward bolstering that part of its business with the purchase of BrightRoll, a programmatic video ad network and a provider of digital video advertising services, for $640 million on Tuesday. Yet another acquisition, though, which is sure to make investors even unhappier.

In her first year as CEO, Yahoo's stock rose nearly 75% with Mayer at the helm. At the end of trading on July 16th of 2012, the company's stock was $15.65 a share. At the end of trading Monday, Yahoo's stock was up 0.4%, or 11 cents, to $27.34 a share.

It is currently trading at $50.46 as of Wednesday, meaning it has now more than tripled since Mayer took over. 

A spokesperson from AOL had no comment on the report. Yahoo could not be reached for comment at this time, and we will update if we learn more. 

(Image source:

Support VatorNews by Donating

Read more from our "Trends and news" series

More episodes

Related Companies, Investors, and Entrepreneurs

BrightRoll, Inc.


Joined Vator on

Led by a team of Internet advertising veterans and engineers, BrightRoll has served billions of advertisements since we got started. We achieved this growth by enabling agencies and brand advertisers to execute smart video ad campaigns across the industry’s leading publishers, including over half of the top 250 websites in the United States.

Dozens of advertising agencies work with BrightRoll to execute campaigns for their premier brands. By offering full site disclosure, detailed performance reports and flexible targeting, we provide advertisers with the reach, frequency, scalability, and transparency needed to achieve their goals.

Hundreds of branded publishers work with BrightRoll to maximize the value of their online inventory. We are fortunate to work with many of the Internet’s leading branded publishers, including multiple television properties, and most of the leading high-volume video sites.

BrightRoll is headquartered in San Francisco, CA, and has sales offices throughout the United States.


Marissa Mayer

Joined Vator on