MetroZONE and the move to serendipitous, relevant contentRead more...
Aka how far into this article will you switch to puppy videos?
A long, long time ago, in a galaxy called 1992, Robin Williams starred in a movie about a toy factory. They called this movie “Toys”, which was not a clever name for a movie, but it was descriptive. The movie had a lot of toys, and in that year, Matt was all about it. And so it was, that on a recent rainy Saturday (ok fine it was a perfectly nice day out), I fired up Netflix and searched “Toys.”
And thus, my adventure down the rabbit hole began…
First there was a documentary about the toys we grew up with in the 80’s. Then an international film about a toymaker coping with his own mortality. Oh look, a Kevin Smith documentary about those little vinyl figures. Hey, a Netflix short-form series about eSports (I guess this is a toy.). And the cartoons. So many cartoons. It was overwhelming, and I hadn’t even checked HBO. So I did what most people do, I put on an episode of Queer Eye that I’d already seen twice.
Choices are good, I’m not here to convince you otherwise. There are 500 original scripted TV shows and 750 reality TV shows in production right now and. A fifth of those scripted shows were created by Netflix which, didn’t even have original programming until a few short years ago. That’s wild.
It almost makes me wistful for what the early days of television must have been like. Programming was simple. Morning cartoons, daytime soap operas, and prime time entertainment ran like clockwork, based on an average demographic of age and gender.
Not to mention if you missed it, you missed it. There was no ghostly haunting of a new show moaning through through the rafters of your queue every time you sat down to ponder what to watch next before someone spoiled it. (Too dramatic?)
I don’t know how they measure the attention span of a goldfish - Ani DiFranco once described it as “the little plastic castle is a surprise every time!” - but they say ours is even shorter. We’ve got mountains of everlasting new content every day, and if you’re one of those people looking to tell a new story you’re definitely struggling with how to find your audience.
I talked to a few publishers who are tackling this problem in a few different ways. Because audiences vary across mobile, TV, desktop, and voice-enabled platforms, they’ve been repurposing their content to adapt. But, they haven’t lost sight of that balance of emotionally driven, human content that can learn from the data and technical capabilities we have in 2018.
So what is this? A better channel? A new approach? What does it all mean, Basil?
Screens? Where we’re going, we don’t need screens…
Yes, much of our consumption is on a screen somewhere between 3” and 70” (should you be so lucky). But think of the new platforms we’re seeing become viable in just in the last few years with chatbot APIs and new voice UI devices already crowding the market. It’s hard enough to perfect an existing channel, let alone figure out a new one.
“Today consumers have more choice than ever before when it comes to how, when and where they consume content. They’re either getting a daily app news debrief while commuting on the subway or streaming a football game via tablet while waiting in line at the airport,” said Sean Galligan, Vice President & Industry Lead, Tech & Telecom, Verizon’s Oath, referring to a Pew Research Center report that found the median U.S. household contained five devices: smartphones, desktops, laptops, tablets or streaming media devices.
“In order to stay relevant and top of mind when today’s consumer has all of these choices, brands have to build the best premium experiences. That means creating killer mobile content, trusted mobile data that performs, and mobile-first ad tech.”
Of course, what works in one place might not in another, and that’s important to remind yourself, said Chris Papaleo, Executive Director of Emerging Technology at Hearst.
“We’re very focused on imagining what platform a person is engaging the content. What day that user is likely to encounter this content and what content format works for the device they’re using,” said Papaleo. “You can’t create one piece of content and put that everywhere. It’s very much about content that’s native to the platform. Even Facebook and Snapchat have their own unique characteristics that make our thinking about content on those platforms very different from how we might work elsewhere.”
The smart publisher views this state of affairs, not merely as a challenge, but as an opportunity. Every new platform presents an awesome new creative outlet. (Like a 4D movie with smell-o-vision!)
“The choice and variety of available devices today isn’t all doom and gloom for content creators. It’s an opportunity to connect with audiences at multiple touchpoints, like never before,” said Oath’s Galligan.
Papaleo echoed the sentiment.
“On the more established, mainstream platforms, like Snap and Facebook, it’s about reaching our existing user base where they are,” he said. “Since voice-enabled platforms are still emerging, we can potentially reach a wider audience as we position ourselves to be a quality experience that gets surfaced in response to an organic user question.”
For example, Hearst has a product called “My Beauty Chat” on Amazon’s Alexa, which Papaleo refers to as a “beauty focused content experience on voice.” It draws on the expertise of Hearst’s beauty editors across multiple magazine titles such as Cosmo and Marie Claire. If someone asks Alexa to give them a beauty tip, Alexa might surface up that content. “We believe if it is going to be more convenient for users to search with their voice, rather than type it into their smartphone keyboard or on some other screen, we need to figure out the best pathway to get our information to the user.”
I am a human and I have emotions
So to recap: we’re no longer tracking viewership in Nielsen watching journals (Which is good, I don’t need a paper trail on my Drag Race watching habits #TeamMonet). Detailed statistics on viewership are now the norm, and it means you’ve seen a lot of content driven by knowing just what gets viewed.
Demand Media has created tons of “How to” stories based on the questions most asked online, for example, “How to tie a bow tie.” (Spoiler alert: I still don’t know!) At one point, Demand Media dominated the top of Google searches for most “How to” questions.
Topix leverages a similar methodology, but takes it even further. Their stories aren’t driven by a news cycle, but by emotion. How do they put their finger on the emotional pulse of their audience? They distill it from their 50 top-grossing stories.
“We identified four emotions that were driving the most engagement: nostalgia, schadenfreude, pride of knowledge and humor,” said Chris Tolles, CEO of Topix. “As opposed to using data to build a relationship with an individual, or deliver more personalized stories, we’re using data that can resonate with a broader population. Since then we’ve produced stories on a small budget that alone have generated three quarters of a million dollars due to the fact that, in this case, the content made people feel nostalgic.”
As an example, stories that have a historical angle can make the reader feel nostalgic. And nostalgia is a super powerful emotion (we’re not biased at all…). Moreover, stories made to be timeless can evoke these same feelings repeatedly.
“We’re not going to create anything that’s ephemeral,” said Tolles. “If it can’t be interesting a year or a decade from now we’re not going to write about it. Cinderella doesn’t go obsolete; we’re looking at creating things like that and then use data to fine-tune the content for the audiences that are interested.”
Tolles pointed out that this approach to content production is more like following a recipe. It’s a utilitarian form of creativity, not solely artistic, he suggested.
“I came from a background of selling packaged software. If you have a media publication background, you don’t look at stories as stand-alone products, but rather ongoing articles that lose relevance over time,” said Tolles. “For us, we’re trying to make sure people stick with our stories because they have the best emotional connection possible and for as long as possible, which then turns out to be very, very profitable.”
We must go deeper
To every yin, there is a yang. Such is the balance of life. And so it is that for every Topix, there is an Oath. In contrast to Topix’s utilitarian approach, Oath strives to create deeper reader relationships with it's trusted brands. Take for example Tumblr, a platform that creates and cultivates communities of people around specific shared interests. Fun fact: Tumblr’s audience - of which 75 percent are under 34 years old - creates one billion posts a month.
“As a user-led platform where voicing one’s opinion and creativity is encouraged, Tumblr’s community especially rallies around a spectrum of topics from entertainment to activism, allowing its audiences to not only go deeper with content but to connect with others [who are like-minded],” said Oath’s Galligan.
“Not only do users want to go deeper with digital content, brand, character and community but brands must build and reflect that affinity. What audiences are looking for is simple: brand love.” said Galligan.
In a recent study aptly named the Brand Love Index, they called out six key drivers of brand loyalty. Among those drivers is the ability to set trends and take a strong stance on values. According to the study, “people want to be seen using brands that share their values (representing 12% of brand love globally). In the U.S. however, this drives 14% of brand love, more than almost anywhere in the world.”
In other words, if a brand reflects the values of its community, the audience is more inclined to like them. Not exactly a hot take, but it’s important to remember as we witness the polarization of news sites and the increasing number of publications willing to partake in conversations previously deemed… icky.
Pulling It All Together
Now, pair all of that brand-talk with all that new-platform-talk we made earlier. Brands are now willing to have more meaningful conversations, on platforms that feel even more personal. With robot mouth voices!
“The personalized experience is something that’s exciting to be able to do on voice platforms that I don’t believe you have the ability to do when you’re just publishing content on the Internet. That’s one powerful way that we see more personalized experiences evolving though we’re at the early stages of that,” said Hearst’s Papaleo.
“The difference between voice platforms, like Alexa or Google Assistant, vs simply listening to podcasts is the interactive nature of the voice platforms,” Papaleo added, suggesting a person can reveal a lot more about themselves through a conversation. “A small thing we’re starting to build now is tailoring our messages based on someone’s prior engagement with our products though we need a lot more people on those platforms using the products before we have a really great sense of how that pushes the product vision forward.”
And In Conclusion...
Content is tough.
Engaging, emotional, raw content is even tougher.
And there’s no easy answer, but there are a ton of new tools and platforms that sometimes seem to take over so quickly that we forget to take a step back and really think creatively about how we can use them to better connect with people.
The moments when people are engaged with your content are happening more often and in entirely new ways. But even more so, they are happening more and more at the same time.
These goldfish are easily distracted, and these goldfish are your audience. You have to know them really, really well - even down to their goldfish values. If years ago, the lack of options made consumers beholden to the whims of creators, that script has completely flipped.
And that means putting a whole lot of effort into those little plastic castles.
(Keith McCurdy, Steve Loeb and Bambi Francisco Roizen contributed to this piece.)
Read more from our "Thought Leadership" series
AI’s potential to be realized by a diversity of data pulled together in a centralized healthcare mapRead more...
Some of the most important data is coming from claims and EHRs, and new sources like wearablesRead more...
Related Companies, Investors, and Entrepreneurs
Joined Vator on
Timehop is a mobile app that breathes new life into old memories. We help you relive your life, via your photos, tweets, and check-ins, in a daily dose of nostalgia.
Joined Vator on
Topix is the largest news community on the web, connecting people to the information and discussions that matter to them in every U.S. town and city. A Top 20 news destination (Hitwise, July 2007), Topix turns passive news into active dialogue through a scalable forum system and an active community editing platform.