Bmh2019-900

Investor Panels

16340

Every unicorn needs a nemesis

Investors from Shasta, Javelin, Intel, IVP, and Lowercase discuss unicorns at the Series A

Innovation series by Ronny Kerr
December 3, 2015
Short URL: http://vator.tv/n/41d3

Today, there are 145 private companies valued at $1 billion and above. But they all started somewhere.

Identifying a startup that will eventually be a success is hard enough, but an even harder task—identifying the attributes of a baby unicorn—was the topic for a session at this week’s Post Seed (#postseedconf) event in San Francisco.



Interviewed by Alex Konrad (Staff Writer, Forbes), five investors—Tod Francis (Managing Director, Shasta Ventures), Jed Katz (Managing Director, Javelin Venture Partners), Christine Herron (Director, Intel Capital), Tom Loverro (Vice President, Institutional Venture Partners), and Matt Mazeo (Managing Director, Lowercase Capital)—shared their diverse perspectives.

Konrad opened up the session with the obvious question: are there any patterns or attributes you can easily spot in a baby unicorn?

Ironically, Francis argues that unicorns seem insignificant and easy to dismiss at the Series A stage. With Airbnb, nobody thought “couchsurfing would be a big deal, and with Uber, black cars seemed small too.

On the other hand, he continued, they usually focus on a single customer need, and they do that piece really well. That’s important because they’re often going into a competitive market to vastly improve upon a behavior people are already doing, like booking rooms or taxis. Herron would echo this later in the conversation by arguing that “the unwritten rule is you must have a market nemesis” (like the monster hotel or taxi industries) in order to end up a unicorn.

An evangelist-founder is also crucial to the success of a unicorn. Though it’s hard to define what exactly makes a “good” founder, Francis says “you know it when you see it. They have a way of making everyone in the room believe what they’re saying.”

Even at the Series A stage, when the data is still lacking, these founders pitch a big vision and have mastered the art of storytelling. Mazeo agreed, saying that all founders leading $1 billion companies use the future perfect tense: “This will happen.” “When this happens, we will…” Nothing is just “possible,” but rather there is an underlying assumption that things will progress according to a plan of execution.

Put another way, it sounds like future unicorn founders are cocky and great bullshitters. But does an investor really want to hear an entrepreneur at the Series A stage saying, “My company will be a unicorn”?

“No,” said Herron flatly. “It’s like a guy on a date saying, ‘I’m going to marry you.’”

The fact of the matter is that you can’t get from A to Z until you hit B, C, D, etc. Founders have to be intellectually honest, data-driven, and able to iterate. They do not live in an ego vacuum with their own great ideas, but listen closely to the market and respond accordingly.

All the investors on stage echoed this sentiment, with Mazeo offering an example of how they filter out the BS. He always asks entrepreneurs what success looks like to them. Great founders say they’re going to solve or improve upon a problem, while “mercenary” founders bring up valuations, exits, and returns.

This goes hand in hand with the idea that an early unicorn founder won’t be the most polished. Mazeo joked about how early interviews with Facebook’s Mark Zuckerberg show a kid in a hoodie, sweating everywhere, not selling a beautiful machine but a product with duct tape holding everything together. And yet he, like other founders of today's successful companies, had a “visceral understanding of the solution they were bringing to market.”

Indeed, inexperience might be an important ingredient, since some great entrepreneurs don’t understand why certain businesses are completely broken. They haven’t seen it from the inside; they just want to make it better.

While founders are part of the formula, there must be a reason why there are so many unicorns today. Though an over-exuberant VC climate has something to do with it, there’s also something to the fact that the market is prime for new businesses.

As Herron put it, you don’t have Uber until you have a critical mass of smartphones.


Related companies, investors and entrepreneurs

13534
Intel Capital
Angel group/VC
Description: Whether you're seed stage or ready for growth, Intel Capital can help take it to the next level. Since 1991, we have invested more than ...
14564
Javelin Venture Partners
Angel group/VC
Description: Invests in early-stage tech companies with incredible potential, managed by teams of energetic, trustworthy and capable leaders. Key focu...
Description: With $7 billion of committed capital, IVP is one of the premier later-stage venture capital and growth equity firms in the United States....
Bio: Tom is a Vice President at IVP. He focuses on investing in later-stage, high-growth consumer and enterprise companies. Tom curr...
Bio: Jed Katz is the Managing Director of Javelin Venture Partners. One of the pioneers of online commerce, Jed has spent his 20 yea...
Bio: Tod Francis is with Shasta Ventures. He focuses his investing activity on early stage companies that leverage technology to im...

Related news

Get-listed-300x250

Featured Stories

Vatorx1

Other episodes of this series

What digital health trends are VCs...

18794

Investor Panels

by Mitos Suson
VCs from Canvas Ventures, McKesson Ventures, Sequoia Capital, Xfund at Splash Health 2017

Video: Post Seed and Small A round is a big...

18581

Investor Panels

by Mitos Suson
At Post Seed 2016, Founders and Partners discussed about Post Seed and Small A Round

Video: Getting to a super-sized A round and...

18579

Investor Panels

by Mitos Suson
At Post Seed 2016, CEOs and Partners talked about the size of their funds and investment

Video: Investing in categories no one is...

18572

Investor Panels

by Mitos Suson
At Post Seed 2016, Co-founders and partners shared their ideas about missed investment categories

Video: CEOs who navigated the Post Seed...

18574

Investor Panels

by Mitos Suson
At Post Seed 2016, founder-CEOs discussed the reasons behind their decisions to raising post seed
Vatorx1