Is semantic technology helping ads? Hardly

Former president of IAB, Greg Stuart, says semantic technology isn't close to improving targeting


Investor interview by Bambi Francisco
July 2, 2009 | Comments (6)
Short URL: http://vator.tv/n/926

5

"The promise of semantics is to bring a level of intelligence [to advertising]," said former Interactive Advertising Bureau President Greg Stuart. "It’s not quite there... advertising based on semantic technology isn't even close to improving targeting."

I ran into Stuart at the 2009 Semantic Technology conference. Stuart was on a couple panels discussing semantics as it applies to advertising and publishing. Stuart also headed the IAB, an organization that creates standards for the online advertising industry.  So, who better to talk to about whether advertising was getting smarter - in other words better targeted - with the integration of semantic technology?  

In software, semantic technology essentially provides a layer of meaning-centered code on top of existing technologies. In other words, software should realize that someone reading an article about gaming company Digital Chocolate probably isn't interested in an advertisement for Ghirardelli chocolates. This has been a problem that advertising companies have been trying to solve for a long time. They still don't have it right and semantic technology hasn't helped, according to Stuart.

Stuart, who happens to also be an angel investor, and who's also seeking an operational role at an advertising or media-related startup, says he hasn't found that billion-dollar-semantic idea yet.


Related companies, investors and entrepreneurs

6 comments

Comment_gbg
Mike Darnell, 134 days ago
Hi Bambi, Thanks for this great interview. Personally I think Semantic Web technology is beginning to deliver fairly well on it's promise in verticals such as news, business and entertainment that are already relatively content rich. The technology will improve for other verticals as well as the quantity of online data related to them increases. I've explained my thoughts on this in depth on Social Computing Journal here: http://socialcomputingjournal.com/viewcolumn.cfm?colid=818 and here: http://socialcomputingjournal.com/viewcolumn.cfm?colid=810 Cheers, Mike @pop_art Disclosure - I am project manager at SemantiNet - a company dedicated to developing Semantic Web technologies. Check out our 1st product - Semantic Web Firefox addon http://Headup.com

Login to reply Mike


Bambi Francisco
Bambi Francisco, 134 days ago
Thanks, Mike I agree that semantic technology appears to be getting traction in the publishing industry. I think the shopping scenario you point out in your piece is a good explanation of what the Web can be in the future. But you also point out in your piece: "A key element to remember about an ideal Semantic Web is that it's a web of data where everything is perfectly defined and linked, and moreover all the data is structured and accessible to computers. When all the data about everything is available online and accessible to computers shopping... " So, will we ever reach that Semantic Web utopia so online shopping is more than just a "digitally-enhanced bargain hunt?"

Login to reply Bambi


Comment_gbg
Mike Darnell, 134 days ago
You're correct in assessing me as optimist. The vision of a "perfect semantic web" may well be Utopian. But one can dream... : ) In the immediate future we'll see better, faster and hopefully, cooler bargain hunting, and slowly that will evolve into something more exciting. Mike @pop_art

Login to reply Mike


Bambi Francisco
Bambi Francisco, 134 days ago
It'll be fun to watch! If you're ever interested in being a VatorNews contributor let me know. I enjoy your work.

Login to reply Bambi


Comment_gbg
Mike Darnell, 133 days ago
I'd be honored! I'm connecting with you via the site... : ) Mike @pop_art

Login to reply Mike


Comment_gbg
Mike Darnell, 131 days ago
Following the discussion here I've linked to a screenshot demonstrating exactly how powerful Semantic Web technology can be for advertising. I took the liberty of running this specific page through our Alpha phase publishers' widget demo. Interestingly not only was the technology capable of identifying both Greg Stuart and Digital Chocolate correctly, it also displayed contextually relevant content related for both: http://www.flickr.com/photos/33393716@N03/3712438222 http://www.flickr.com/photos/33393716@N03/3712475636 As the screen shots demonstrate current Semantic Web technology is already capable of identifying obvious contextual relevance and also able to bring in content supporting it. What remains to be seen is how well users will react to the advertising and affiliation links the technology will offer them? Mike @pop_art | @headup

Login to reply Mike


Courses are developed to give you the tools and expertise you need to rapidly scale your business.

Latest company updates on Vator.tv

Bancroft Research Group - Mark Evans (Managing Principal)
Good for all you entrepreneurs who work from home - how to do it without going ...
See more about 2 hours ago
Giftventure.com - Steve Mock (Founder and CEO)
We just cut a deal with Santa. He's moving to Vegas... http://bit.ly/7wFg1z
See more about 3 hours ago
rentcycle - Tim Hyer (Founder)
Rentcycle lands another SF client, Big Swingin' Cycles! Check out the homepage: http://www.bigswingincycles.com/
See more about 5 hours ago, 1 thumbs up
Neputation joined the competition "Vator Splash Competition", vote for them! about 5 hours ago
Thumbtack.com's data was edited about 6 hours ago
© 2009 Vator, Inc.